NEW ZEALAND DISASTERS AND TRAGEDIES
THE SINKING OF SS CHAKDINA
TORPEDOED IN THE MEDITERRANEAN SEA BY ENEMY ACTION WITH THE LOSS OF 89* NEW ZEALAND SOLDIERS
FRIDAY 5 DECEMBER 1941
Late in the afternoon of 5 December 1941 the SS Chakdina left Tobruk Harbour, Libya carrying approximately 380 wounded Allied soldiers, 100 German and Italian Prisoners of War and 120 crew. A number of other Allied soldiers also boarded the ship. They were to be transported back to Egypt. At least 123 New Zealanders were aboard the shop when it set sail.
Just after 9 pm an enemy plane released a torpedo, which exploded in one of the after holds of the Chakdina. She sank within three and a half minutes. There was very little chance of escape, except for those who were not wounded or only lightly wounded, and who were in a favourable position at the time.
OForty one of the New Zealanders aboard including a small number of the wounded were picked up by the destroyer HMS Farndale and the antisubmarine/minesweeper HMS Thorgrim. The Farndale took most of the survivors to Alexandria where on 7 December, the casualties were admitted to the detachment of 3 NZ General Hospital there. The Thorgrim took the survivors it had onboard to Mersa Matuh. The sinking of the Chakdina was the only major misfortune in the evacuation of New Zealand wounded during World War Two.
For further information see -
2nd New Zealand Divisional Artillery - The Sinking of the Chakdina
Medical Units of 2 NZEF in Middle East and Italy -
Sinking of SS Chakdina
Australian Casualties of the SS Chakinda
Thank you to Brian Sims of Mansfield Woodhouse, Nottinghamshire and Robert Loughnan for their help with the above information and for the names of those killed in the sinking of the SS Chakdina. Those killed are remembered on the Alamein Memorial, Egypt.
SURNAME | FORENAMES | RANK | SERVICE NO | CODE - SEE BELOW | NEXT OF KIN | REGIMENT | UNIT | AGE |
AIMERS | Jack Bertram | Lieutenant | 63197 | ** | Son of Walter Nelson Aimers and Constance Trevar Aimers, of Rongotai, Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 14 Lt. A.A. Regt. | 26 |
ANDERSON | Norman | Sergeant | 3213 | ** | Son of Gustaf Edward and Georgina Anderson, of Middlesbrough, Yorkshire, England. | New Zealand Infantry | H.Q.Div. Defence and Employment Platoon. | 28 |
ANDREWS | William Keith | L/Bombardier | 61081 | ** | Son of William Alfred and Annie Letitia Andrews, of Nelson, New Zealand; husband of Mavis Annie Andrews. | New Zealand Artillery | 4 Field Regt | 41 |
BAOUMGREN | John Bidwell | Private | 7291 | * | Son of Albert Baoumgren and of Gertrude Sarah Baoumgren (nee Heginbotham), of Kaiwarawara, Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Medical Corps | 4 Field Amb. | 25 |
BLACKMAN | Douglas Arnold | Corporal | 23542 | ** | Born 14 Jun 1912. Probate at Archives NZ - Wellington | New Zealand Infantry | 24th Bn. | 29 |
BOOTH | Jack | Gunner | 25493 | ** | Son of Samuel Booth and of Alice Booth (nee Mills), of Bradford, Yorkshire, England. | New Zealand Artillery | - | 36 |
BROWN | Charles Henry | Gunner | 25505 | ** | Son of Charles Henry and Marion Sarah Brown, of Dannevirke, Hawke's Bay, New Zealand; husband of Myra Rose Brown, of Dannevirke. | New Zealand Artillery | 6 Field Regt. | 36 |
BRUNTON | Alan George | Private | 29506 | * | Born 30 Aug 1910. Probate at Archives NZ - Wellington | New Zealand Infantry | 18th Bn. | 31 |
BUCHANAN | Malcolm James | Sergeant | 60066 | ** | Son of John and Bertha Jessie Buchanan, of Waverley, New South Wales, Australia; husband of Margaret Buchanan, of Mount Roskill, Auckland, New Zealand. Awarded Military Medal | New Zealand Artillery | 4 Field Regt | 28 |
BUNN | Ronald D'Arcy | Corporal | 23909 | ** | Son of Ernest and Jessie McFarlane Bunn, of Paparangi, Wanganui, Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | H.Q. Coy., 24th Bn. | 23 |
BURNETT | James Otterson | 2/Lieutenant | 34082 | ** | Son of James Edmund Maurice Burnett and of Kathleen Burnett (nee Otterson), of Karori, Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 4 Field Regt | 24 |
BURNS | Wadlow Neiafu Campbell | Private | 7848 | ** | Son of Robert Nelson Burns and of Ada May Burns (nee Marchant), of Brown's Bay, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Machine Gun Battalion | 27th (Machine Gun) N.Z. Bn. | 27 |
CAMERON | Colin | Driver | 26456 | ** | Son of Ewen Stewart Cameron and of Sarah Cameron (nee Renton), of Te Kuiti, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Army Service Corps | - | 22 |
CHILD | Phillip | Private | 29884 | ** | Son of Garnet Eric and Ethel Mary Child, of Maungakaramea, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 24th Bn. | 30 |
CHRISP | Arnold Dickson | Gunner | 20140 | ** | Son of Capt. Arthur Dawson Chrisp and Emma Margaret Chrisp, of Gisborne, Auckland, New Zealand; husband of Josephine Elizabeth Chrisp, of Raumati Beach, Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 7 Anti Tank Regt. | 37 |
COOPER | Douglas Isbister | Private | 13262 | * | Born 09 Nov 1917. Probate at Archives NZ - Wellington | New Zealand Medical Corps | - | 24 |
CURSONS | Thomas James | Gunner | 29113 | * | Son of Thomas Henry and Laura Christina Cursons, of Christchurch, Canterbury, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 7 Anti Tank Regt. | 22 |
CURTIS | James Leonard | Private | 14434 | * | Son of William Leonard Curtis and of Anna Townsend Curtis (nee Holland). | New Zealand Infantry | 18th Bn. | 37 |
CUTHBERTSON | Henry Francis | Sergeant | 1789 | * | Son of Robert Cuthbertson and of Helen Cuthbertson (nee Peterson), of Dunedin, Otago, New Zealand; husband of Margaret Alice Cuthbertson, of Dunedin. | New Zealand Artillery | 4 Field Regt | 37 |
DARLING | John Temple | Private | 8504 | ** | Son of John and Elizabeth Darling, of Dunedin, Otago, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 20th Bn | 31 |
DAY | Alfred | Private | 23012 | ** | Son of Sidney and Lucy Matilda Day; husband of M. E. Day, of Eden Terrace, Auckland City, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 24th Bn. | 30 |
DICKENS | Bruce Gerard | Gunner | 24484 | ** | Son of Alfred Dickens and of Teresa Dickens (nee Green), of Wellington City, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 6 Field Regt. | 23 |
DICKSON | Charles John | Private | 17371 | ** | Son of Charles Miller Dickson and Isabell Frances Dickson, of Invercargill, Southland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | - | 22 |
DOLAMORE | John Bruce | Sergeant | 20206 | ** | Born 01 Feb 1915. Probate at Archives NZ - Wellington | New Zealand Artillery | 5 Field Regt. | 26 |
FEENEY | John | Captain | 4538 | ** | Son of John and M. Feeney, of Glasgow, Scotland; husband of of Eileen E. Feeney, of Westmere, Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Corps of Signals | 2 Div. Sigs. | 36 |
FLETCHER | Leicester Charles Clarke | Gunner | 61234 | * | Son of Alfred Ernest and Elizabeth D. Fletcher, of St. Albans, Christchurch, Canterbury, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 5 Field Regt. | 23 |
GALE | John William Hunter | Private | 16604 | ** | Son of Joseph Hopkinson Gale and Benjamina Gale, of Linwood, Canterbury, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 20th Bn | 22 |
GERRARD | Jack Lloyd | Gunner | 1605 | ** | Son of Herbert J. and Florence Gerrard, of Devonport, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 4 Field Regt | 28 |
HAIGH | Alan Raymond | Gunner | 28943 | * | Son of Ernest Haigh and of Mabel Dorothy Haigh (nee Greathead), of Te Puke, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 6 Field Regt. | 27 |
HALSEY | Henry | Gunner | 61292 | * | Husband of Annie J. Halsey, of Green Island, Otago, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 14 Lt. A.A. Regt. | 29 |
HEERDEGEN | Frederick Basil | Gunner | 61207 | * | Son of Frederick Heerdegen and of Alice Mary Heerdegen (nee Mayo), of Mangaweka, Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 14 Lt. A.A. Regt. | 40 |
HENDERSON | Dugald Cameron | Private | 14222 | * | Son of John and Margaret Henderson, of Invercargill, Southland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | H.Q. Coy., 26th Bn. | 29 |
HENDERSON | Thomas William | Driver | 40876 | * | Son of John William David and Elena Henderson, of Clareville, Wellington, New Zealand; husband of Hazel Mildred Henderson, of Eketahuna, Wellington. | New Zealand Army Service Corps | - | 23 |
HUNSLEY | Russell Stratton | Gunner | 29180 | * | Son of William Stratton Hunsley and Mary B. Hunsley, of Christchurch, Canterbury, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 6 Field Regt. | 26 |
JENSEN | Andrew Edward | Private | 63170 | ? | Son of Anders Clemmen Jensen and of Ruth Jensen (nee Dunning); husband of Frances Lyla Jensen, of Morrinsville, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 21st Bn. | 25 |
JOHNSON | John Alfred | Private | 24104 | * | Son of Walter and Mary Johnson, of Te Aroha, Auckland, New Zealand; husband of Lorna Patricia Johnson, of Sandringham, Auckland. | New Zealand Infantry | 24th Bn. | 23 |
JOHNSTON | James Armistice | Private | 44648 | * | Son of James Johnston and of Caroline Johnston (nee Purcell), of Ponsonby, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Medical Corps | 4 Field Amb | 23 |
KELMAN | Raharuhi Raymond | Private | 15518 | ?? | Son of Robert and Ellen Kelman, of Dunedin, Otago, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | - | 36 |
KILGOUR | James Gordon | Gunner | 25648 | * | Son of James and Lily E. T. Kilgour, of Roxburgh, Otago, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 6 Field Regt. | 23 |
KNOPWOOD | Ernest Llewellyn | L/Corporal | 33115 | * | Son of James Robert and Anne Knopwood, of Gisborne, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Provost Corps | - | 26 |
KNOX | William Andrew | Major | 20018 | * | Son of William Andrew Knox and of Jessie Amelia Knox (nee Stanley), of Herne Bay, Auckland, New Zealand. Served throughout 1914/18 War; Mentioned in Despatches; Commissioned in the Field. October 1916. | New Zealand Artillery | Div. Ord. Field Park. | 48 |
LAMBIE | Frank Thomas | Private | 22088 | * | Son of Andrew Lambie and of Grace Lambie (nee Appleby), of Morrinsville, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 21st Bn. | 23 |
LARSEN | Leonard Howard | Corporal | 35511 | * | Son of Anders A. and Johanne Kristiane Larsen, of Raetihi, Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | - | 25 |
LEE | Gordon Wilfred | Private | 40363 | * | Son of James and Elizabeth Lee, of Hastings, Hawke's Bay, New Zealand. | New Zealand Medical Corps | 4 Field Amb. | 27 |
LEUTY | John Thomas | Private | 60295 | * | Son of Edgar Mawson Leuty and Alice Leuty, of Titirangi, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | - | 22 |
LISTER | Albert James | Gunner | 24617 | * | Son of Peter James Lister and Elizabeth Lister, of Wairoa, Hawke's Bay, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 6 Field Regt. | 30 |
LOGAN | Harold John | Gunner | 24620 | * | Son of John Archer Logan and Mary Elizabeth Logan, of Silverstream, Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 6 Field Regt. | 22 |
LOVEJOY | Rudolph James | Private | 34034 | * | Son of Mrs. P. E. Knight, of Weber, Hawke's Bay, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 19th Bn. | 36 |
LUDEMAN | Henry John | L/Sergeant | 1520 | * | Son of Mr. and Mrs. Samuel George Ludemann, of Masterton, Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 4 Field Regt | 28 |
MACARTY | John McEwan | L/Corporal | 17710 | * | Son of Edwin Stewart Macarty and of Lilian Hannah Macarty (nee McEwan), of Manchester, England; husband of Lilian Macarty, of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia. | New Zealand Infantry | - | 30 |
MACE | Neville | Private | 62837 | ? | Son of Gwendoline M. MacE, of New Plymouth, Taranaki, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | - | 25 |
MADDEN | Stanley Jorden | Private | 30168 | * | Born 11 Jan 1917. Probate at Archives NZ - Wellington | New Zealand Medical Corps | 5 Field Amb | 24 |
MALIN | Walter Raymond Henry | WO1 | 5845 | ? | Born 22 Dec 1916. Probate at Archives NZ - Wellington | New Zealand Provost Corps | Div. Provost Coy. | 24 |
McCONNELL | Spencer Allan Stuart | Private | 29778 | * | Son of George McConnell, and of Pearl McConnell (nee Harris), of Riponui, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 18th Bn. | 23 |
McKAY | Brian | Private | 20088 | ? | Son of Henry McKay and of Mabel Priscilla McKay (nee Kirk), of Hastings, Hawke's Bay, New Zealand; husband of Joyce V. McKay, of Ponsonby, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 21st Bn. | 23 |
McLEAY | Kenneth Andrew | Sergeant | 20235 | * | Son of Kenneth and Mary Eliza McLeay, of Napier, Hawke's Bay, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 5 Field Regt. | 23 |
McNAMARA | Neil Joseph | Private | 37120 | * | Born 28 May 1919. Probate at Archives NZ - Wellington | New Zealand Medical Corps | 4 Field Amb | 22 |
McNAMARA | Walter | Private | 2957 | * | Son of Patrick McNamara and of Sarah McNamara (nee Hennessy), of Auckland City, New Zealand | New Zealand Infantry | 18th Bn. | 29 |
MITCHELL | Andrew Albert James | Private | 62125 | ? | Son of Hugh and Catherine Mary Mitchell, of Auckland City, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 21st Bn. | 24 |
MORRISSEY | Michael | Private | 14492 | * | Son of Martin Morrissey and of Maren Morrissey, of Dannevirke, Hawke's Bay, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 18th Bn. | 31 |
O'CONNOR | Hector Victor | Private | 29414 | * | Son of John and Jane Ellen O'Connor. | New Zealand Infantry | 24th Bn. | 30 |
PAORA | Waihora | Private | 25970 | ? | Son of Paona and Kawhena Paora, of Wainui, Canterbury, New Zealand; husband of Kate Paora, of Wainui. | New Zealand Infantry | 28th (Maori) Bn. | 24 |
PERRY | Robert Samuel | Signalman | 33322 | * | Son of F. W. Perry and of Ida Margaret Perry (nee Crutchley), of Johnsonville, Wellington City, New Zealand. | New Zealand Corps of Signals | - | 22 |
PETERSEN | Frank Knight | Gunner | 24708 | ** | Son of Christian Edward and Emily Petersen, of Palmerston, Otago, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 6 Field Regt. | 24 |
PRESTON | Victor Michael | Private | 37596 | * | Son of Herbert Henry and Gladys Victoria Preston, of Dunedin, Otago, New Zealand. | New Zealand Machine Gun Battalion | 27th (Machine Gun) N.Z. Bn. | 22 |
PRITCHARD | William | Gunner | 17852 | * | Son of William Charles Pritchard and of Josephine Marjorie Pritchard (nee McGinn), of Ashburton, Canterbury, New Zealand; husband of Edith Ivy Pritchard, of Ashburton. | New Zealand Artillery | 7 Anti Tank Regt. | 26 |
RAE | William | Private | 17117 | * | Son of John Rae and of Agnes Rae (nee Hastings), of Falkirk, Stirlingshire, Scotland. | New Zealand Infantry | - | 22 |
RAMSEY | Charles Harold | Private | 2712 | * | Son of Harold Vivian and Bessie Jane Ramsey, of Taheke, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 18th Bn. | 27 |
REID | John Henry | Gunner | 63747 | * | Son of John Henry Reid and of Fanny Harriet Reid (nee Carey), of Kokonga, Otago, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 6 Field Regt. | 31 |
RICHARDS | George | Sapper | 36395 | * | Son of Charles and Sophie Richards, of Wanganui, Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Engineers | 6 Field Coy. | 28 |
RUDDICK | Percy Edward | Private | 24272 | * | Son of Robert and Agnes Isabelle Ruddick, of Taneatua, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 24th Bn. | 23 |
RUTHERFORD | Frederick Duncan | 2/Lieutenant | 11749 | * | Son of Leslie Ashin Rutherford and Lucy Margaret Rutherford, of Hawarden, Canterbury, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 25th Bn. | 29 |
SCOTT | Kenneth Alexander | Gunner | 36046 | * | Son of Alexander and Lottie Mayfield Scott, of Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 5 Field Regt. | 31 |
SEYMOUR | Henry Frank | Gunner | 25797 | * | Son of Charles Henry Seymour and of A. A. R. Seymour (nee Ingram), of Whangara (north of Gisborne), East Coast, New Zealand; husband of Barbara H. Seymour, of Tolaga Bay, Auckland. | New Zealand Artillery | 4 Field Regt | 32 |
SHILLING | Robert Douglas | L/Corporal | 21467 | * | Son of James Augustus and Marie Magdalene Shilling, of Manunui, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 21st Bn. | 23 |
SKUDDER | John Cheeseman | Private | 36477 | ? | Born 04 Aug 1918. Probate at Archives NZ - Wellington | New Zealand Machine Gun Battalion | 27th (Machine Gun) N.Z. Bn. | 23 |
SMEATON | Clarence Raymond | Private | 62844 | * | Son of Ivan Graham Smeaton and Isabel Georgina Mary Smeaton, of Eketahuna, Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 21st Bn. | 23 |
STANLEY | Joseph Allan | Trooper | 17667 | * | Son of Herbert Andrew and Clara Emily Stanley, of Te Aroha, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Armoured Corps | - | 26 |
STEPHENSON | Henry | Private | 16923 | * | Son of Duncan McLaren Stephenson and Ellen Stephenson; husband of Ruby Stephenson, of Anderson's Bay, Dunedin, Otago, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 18th Bn. | 25 |
STIMPSON | Harry Benjamin | Gunner | 61859 | * | Son of Benjamin John and Hedwig Elizabeth Stimpson; husband of Florence Anza Irene Stimpson, of Huntly, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 6 Field Regt. | 25 |
SUNLEY | William Harold | Private | 2732 | * | Son of Harry and Mary Jane Sunley, of Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 18th Bn. | 35 |
TEMM | Carl Albert | Private | 21477 | ? | Son of William Carl Frederick Temm and of Ivy Vivian Temm (nee Woolley), of Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 21st Bn. | 23 |
THOMPSON | Robert | Private | 25404 | * | Son of Robert and Ruth Alice Thompson, of Felling, Co. Durham, England. | New Zealand Infantry | 24th Bn. | 35 |
WALDEN | Arthur Leslie | Private | 2018 | * | Son of John Elliott Walden and Harriet Priscilla Walden, of Wellington, New Zealand; husband of Catherine Murray Walden, of Te Kuiti, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 18th Bn. | 24 |
WALKER | James Robert | Private | 14455 | * | Son of Alfred Boyton Walker and of Annabella Walker (nee Carmichael), of Hawera, Taranaki, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 18th Bn. | 23 |
WALLACE | Hugh Sinclair | Private | 28353 | * | Son of William Sinclair Wallace and Violet Helena Wallace, of Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 24th Bn. | 28 |
WARE | Percival Raymond | Private | 6725 | ? | Son of William John and Annie Mary Ware, of Napier, Hawke's Bay, New Zealand. | New Zealand Infantry | 22nd Bn. | 34 |
WILSON | John Ivan | Bombardier | 60163 | * | Son of Albert and Ruby Ireine Wilson, of Wellington, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 14 Lt. A.A. Regt. | 22 |
WILSON | Raymond Stein | Bombardier | 60065 | * | Son of John Stein Wilson and of Nellie Isabel Wilson (nee Hutchinson), Whangarei, Auckland, New Zealand. | New Zealand Artillery | 6 Field Regt. | 23 |
* - Lost on Chakdina - File WO 361/131 UK Archives
** - Lost on Chakdina and included on CWGC records
*? - Not in WO 361/131 but listed by CWGC as lost on Chakdina
? - Not in WO 361/131 but remembered on Alamein Memorial with Date of Death as 5 December 1941.
Total 74 known to have been lost on Chakdina with 15 possibles.
Also killed was Alfred James Powell
Private S/ 12732605
Royal Army Service Corps 13 Field Bakery
His family had always assumed he was killed in France. It was only when they got a copy of his service records that they found out he was in Egypt. They have not been able to find out what he was doing on the Chakdina. [Chantal Powell August 2015].
FAMILIES I AM RESEARCHING | MISCELLANEOUS GENEALOGICAL STUFF | NEW ZEALAND — ON LINE GENEALOGICAL AND FAMILY HISTORY RESOURCES | NEW ZEALAND — YOUNG BOY IMMIGRANT SCHEME 1911 — 1914 | NEW ZEALAND DISASTERS AND TRAGEDIES | NEW ZEALAND MISCELLANEOUS GENEALOGICAL INDEXES | NEW ZEALAND LAND WARS — MISCELLANEOUS GENEALOGICAL INDEXES | NEW ZEALAND AND WORLD WAR ONE | NEW ZEALAND AND WORLD WAR TWO | NEW ZEALAND ROLLS OF HONOUR AND WAR MEMORIALS — BY LOCATION | NEW ZEALAND ROLLS OF HONOUR AND WAR MEMORIALS — BY CONFLICT | NEW ZEALAND ROLLS OF HONOUR — MILITARY NURSES | PAKEHA/MAORI TRANSLITERATIONS | PASSENGER LISTS TO NEW ZEALAND | SHAND — FAMILY HISTORY | SOUTH TARANAKI, NEW ZEALAND — GENEALOGICAL RESOURCES | SPONDON, DERBYSHIRE, ENGLAND — GENEALOGICAL RESOURCES | WANGANUI COLLEGIATE SCHOOL 1865 — 1947 | WESTERN BAY OF PLENTY, NEW ZEALAND — GENEALOGICAL RESOURCES